```html

Review Form – Revista Médica de la Caja de Seguro Social (RMCSS)

Please rate each of the following elements of the manuscript.

1. Is the material original? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

2. Is it relevant to public health? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

3. Is it written clearly and concisely? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

4. Is the methodology adequately described and justified? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

5. Are the results valid and appropriately presented? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

6. Is the discussion relevant and well supported? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

7. Are the conclusions adequately supported? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

8. Do the figures, tables, and references comply with the journal's standards? *

•  Yes
•  No
•  Unclear
•  Not applicable

General Comments to the Author: *

Recommendation: *

•  Accept without changes
•  Accept with minor revisions
•  Accept with major revisions
•  Reject

Comments to the Editor: *

Reviewer Name: *

Date: *

 

* Required

```